Sex in The Mentalist

I’ve started my annual playthrough of Satisfactory, and I’ve got The Mentalist on in the background – you know, something I’ve not seen before, something to rattle along while I’m layering up conveyor belts. The Mentalist (2008-2015) is an early 2010s American police procedural where a kooky genius helps the police solve crimes. It’s in the same genre as Bones and Monk, or Numb3rs – oh shit, I just remembered that Numb3rs exists – okay, if you’re not familiar, Numb3rs is yet another police procedural, but in this one he solves crimes with math. It’s one of those shows where it’s just really convenient that all these crimes keep happening within the math guy’s specific area of expertise, and also his will-they-won’t-they love interest is played by Navi Rawat, who turns up again as an assassin in Season Four of Burn Notice. Anyway – in The Mentalist the kooky genius is Patrick Jane (played by Simon Baker), an ex-psychic who uses his powers of observation and behavioural analysis to solve crimes instead of pretending to talk to the dead. Jane isn’t a cop, but he’s seconded to the CBI (like the FBI, but for California) as a special consultant, where he’s overseen by the detective Teresa Lisbon. The dynamic between Jane and Lisbon is a fairly well-established trope – it’s the erratic male genius and the accompanying female support. This trope is sometimes associated with some sort of overt mental health problem (as in Monk, where Monk has a literal caregiver / support person due to his OCD), but it’s also just seen as an aspect of the way in which genius (in the scope of these shows) refuses the constraints of the modern workplace. You see it in House, for instance, where House’s opioid addiction and B&E charges are stage-managed by Lisa Cuddy, the long-suffering Dean of Medicine. In The Mentalist, it’s the same basic dynamic. Jane runs around playing his silly mind games and Lisbon has to clean up the procedural and legal issues, as when Jane tricks a murderer into confessing by faking a bomb threat.

Within the first season, most of the episodes involve some sort of misdirection, either with the murder or with its resolution. In Episode Twenty, ‘Red Sauce’, this guy in witness protection gets killed, and there’s fluff about whether the mafia tracked him down, but it turns out his wife just got pissed off and shot him (fair enough). Alternately, many episodes end with Jane luring out the criminal through some sort of melodramatic performance. In the same episode, for instance, Jane tricks the wife into confessing by making it look like the mafia are coming after her. Or – this one’s good – in Episode Ten, ‘Red Brick and Ivy’, there’s this machine that turns people good or evil, through science, and they pretend to turn Jane evil, and then he threatens to shoot people unless the murderer confesses – the machine doesn’t work and it’s all a con, but that’s sort of the energy of the whole show.

The show is also really fixated on people having affairs? Nearly every episode has someone cheating on their spouse, or some sort of illicit relationship causing drama. Episode Twenty-Two, ‘Blood Brothers’, has a camp counsellor sleeping with a fifteen-year old – although admittedly that one was fairly unusual. Normally it’s just straightforward affairs. Episode Four, ‘Ladies in Red’, is built around the conflict between a banker’s wife and secret mistress. In Episode Five, ‘Redwood’, one woman finds out her friend is sleeping with with her boyfriend, and then they’re both attacked by a murderer (for unrelated reasons). In Episode Six, ‘Red Handed’, one guy’s alibi hinges on his affair with the murder victim’s wife, and in Episode Seven, ‘Seeing Red’, an heiress has tension with her children because she starts dating some skeezy photographer after her husband dies – not a literal affair, but felt by her children as an emotional betrayal. Sometimes the misdirect and the affair are connected – the next episode after the heiress, ‘The Thin Red Line’, has a son murder his dad’s secret lover, but because the secret lover was involved in a narcotics case, everybody thinks it’s a hit to stop the prosecution. For those keeping score at home, that’s the same plot twist as in ‘Red Sauce’, where the wife kills her husband because he’s having an affair with his witness protection handler.

Within the show’s narrative vocabulary, then, sex is often covert and illicit. It’s associated with violence and crime – people who have affairs either get murdered or get investigated for murder, with their affair coming to light as part of the investigation. Partly I think that’s a voyeuristic function that’s inherent in this sort of television – maybe more explicitly so in other procedurals. Some procedurals seem to take the approach of exploring a type of life that most people won’t be able to access. I want to say CSI: Miami falls into this category – most people don’t live in Miami, right, so there’s an inherent aspect of tourism to the show. It’s not necessarily realistic, but that’s – you know, not necessarily the function of tourism anyway. Other shows take a ‘slice of life’ approach, where it’s less about the portrayal of a specific place and more about the spectrum of different walks of life. The Mentalist falls into the latter category – as noted, you’ve got scientists, mafia, and camp counsellors all in the first season. The impulse to peer into these different lives is then linked with a certain nosiness about prurient matters. We’re already crossing social boundaries by becoming so intimate with the private details of fictional strangers – we might as well poke around in their sex lives. Murder is the justification, but nosiness is the motivating force.

With that framing of sex in the show, what’s interesting is the romantic relationship within the police team, particularly in the first season. Aside from Jane and Lisbon, there’s a broader cast of supporting characters, all with different attitudes towards Jane and his mentalism. Detective Cho and Inspector Lisbon are the hard-bitten career professionals, unfazed and unflappable. Grace van Pelt and Rigsby are the juniors, both credulous in different ways. Van Pelt is the beautiful rookie, and Rigsby is the lunkhead ass-kicker. In one episode, Jane picks a lock to break into a house, and Cho distracts Rigsby by going ‘hey what’s that over there’. Both Jane and Cho are comfortable with plausible deniability, but Rigsby – the naive rule-follower – needs distracting. He protests once he realizes they’re breaking in, and they go well, you know, door was open, nothing happening here haha.Van Pelt is also set up as the believer, as Mulder to Lisbon’s Scully or as innocence to experience. In early episodes, she confronts Jane when he gets sarcastic about a rival psychic, who Jane (being previously a fraud himself) assumes is a fake. Van Pelt has this whole go at him where she’s like well what if she can speak to spirits, and she could help you talk to your dead wife and kid, but you’re missing out because you don’t want to believe. Naturally, Rigsby and van Pelt are deeply in love, but they won’t act on it for fear of being dropped off the unit, reassigned due to their conflict of interest. Everyone knows they’re in love – their love, like everything else about them, is characterised by a sort of clumsy naivety, by the innocence of youth. Everywhere else in the show, sex is associated with murder and violence, with secrecy and transgression – but these two cuties, these dumb dumbs, get a cute little wholesome office romance.

This desire to look behind the curtain, in other words, almost seems to create the rot that it’s looking for. The cynics see only infidelity. They unpick the false surface of polite society and drag out the grubby reality of broken marriages and betrayed spouses. It takes the naivety of Rigsby and van Pelt to have a shot at genuine love. Jane goes round acting like a mind-reader, and sometimes Rigsby and van Pelt think he actually might be psychic. They believe the superficial lie. Cho and Lisbon roll their eyes at Jane’s silly tricks and deal with the hard-nosed reality underneath – they are the realists, the skeptics, the ones able to see the world for what it is. But it’s Rigsby and van Pelt who find romance. In a world full of secret affairs and fake psychics, it’s the ones who believe the surface lie who have the best time falling in love.

Leave a Reply